I was the editor of a secular newspaper for years. I always kept my office door open, especially if i was talking to a woman or female employee...

I really dont get the criticism of the idea. it protects everyone. Except that everything christian is criticized these days.

never being alone with a woman is extreme, but in genaeral if you are a public figure, it protects you and the woman.

i dont think it should apply to people who are not in the public eye so to speak